Kansas City & Kansas / School Comparison
Best Catholic High Schools in Kansas City & Kansas (2026)
Kansas City families have more strong Catholic high schools than most metros — on both sides of the state line. Within a 20-minute drive of downtown you can find coed schools like Bishop Miege and St. Thomas Aquinas, all-boys Jesuit Rockhurst, all-girls St. Teresa’s Academy and Notre Dame de Sion, the corporate work-study model at Cristo Rey Kansas City, and the fast-growing community at St. James Academyin Lenexa. “Best” here is a shortlist, not a verdict: the right school is the one that fits your child’s academics, commute, and community. This guide ranks the best Catholic high schools in Kansas City on both sides of the border, adds the top statewide options for families searching for the best Catholic high school in Kansas, and gives you the admissions facts — including entrance testing — to start comparing today.
The short answer
- Start with both sides of the metro: the KC Catholic market splits across the state line — Kansas-side families usually start with Bishop Miege, St. Thomas Aquinas, and St. James Academy; Missouri-side families with Rockhurst, St. Teresa’s, Notre Dame de Sion, St. Pius X, and Cristo Rey.
- Decide single-gender vs. coed first. Rockhurst is all-boys; St. Teresa’s and Notre Dame de Sion are all-girls; the rest of the list is coed. This one choice narrows the list more than any ranking.
- Compare on fit, plan around dates. Commute, size, academics, and aid decide the school; HSPT dates and application deadlines are logistics to plan around — prep starts with the earliest test date on your shortlist.
- Confirm entrance-test policy with each school. Most KC Catholic high schools use the HSPT or COOP; Bishop Miege verifiably offers the HSPT in December. Policies differ, so confirm before registering.
The best Catholic high schools in Kansas City, MO & KS
The Kansas City metro is the center of gravity for this page because it is the center of gravity for the search: most families looking for the best Catholic high school in Kansas Citylive within a short drive of the state line and want the whole metro, not just one state. These eight schools are the metro’s Catholic high schools that matter for a 2026 search — four on the Kansas side, four on the Missouri side. The order below is a fit-first starting point (size, identity, and admissions clarity), not a review-score ranking.
1. Bishop Miege High School
Best for the most complete all-around option on the Kansas side of the metro: coed, big enough for deep athletics and AP offerings, and the only KC-area school on this list with a confirmed December HSPT date on its admissions page.
2. St. Thomas Aquinas High School
Best for the largest coed Catholic community on the Kansas side — families who want a big, energetic student body with strong academics, arts, and athletics.
3. Rockhurst High School
Best for boys who thrive in a single-gender Jesuit environment with a serious college-prep tradition and a strong alumni network.
4. St. James Academy
Best for families in south Johnson County who want a newer campus (founded 2005) and a tight-knit community that has grown fast to roughly 1,000 students.
5. St. Teresa's Academy
Best for girls who want a single-gender education in the city with a long tradition and a strong sense of sisterhood.
6. Notre Dame de Sion High School
Best for families drawn to a smaller single-gender college-prep school with a distinctive faith and service culture.
7. St. Pius X High School
Best for families north of the river who want a coed Catholic college prep without a long cross-town commute.
8. Cristo Rey Kansas City
Best for families who value the Cristo Rey model: students earn real work experience through corporate work-study, and tuition is need-based.
Best Catholic high schools in Kansas (statewide)
Outside the Kansas City metro, the best Catholic high schools in Kansas cluster in Wichita and Topeka. If your search is statewide rather than metro-based, these four round out the picture — and yes, families searching for the best Catholic schools in Kansas usually mean this exact list.
9. Bishop Carroll Catholic High School
Best for Wichita families who want the largest Catholic high school in Kansas — more than 1,100 students and a full range of programs.
10. Kapaun Mt. Carmel Catholic High School
Best for Wichita families comparing the city’s two big coed Catholic options — Kapaun pairs strong academics with a deep sports tradition.
11. Hayden Catholic High School
Best for Topeka and Shawnee County families — the city’s Catholic high school with a strong local reputation and manageable size.
12. Maur Hill – Mount Academy
Best for families considering a boarding option — the Benedictine school in Atchison is the Kansas Catholic boarding choice and welcomes day students too.
Kansas City & Kansas Catholic high school comparison
| School | Location | Type | Grades | Enrollment | Admission notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bishop Miege High School | Roeland Park, KS | Coed | 9–12 | ~650 | HSPT required — confirmed test offered in December (bishopmiege.com/admissions, July 2026); priority application deadline in November; open house and shadow days in the fall. |
| St. Thomas Aquinas High School | Overland Park, KS | Coed | 9–12 | ~920 | Admission through the archdiocesan process with entrance testing; confirm the current test and dates with the admissions office (stasaints.net). |
| Rockhurst High School | Kansas City, MO | All-boys (Jesuit) | 9–12 | ~890 | Jesuit college prep; an entrance exam is part of admission — confirm the current exam and dates (rockhursths.edu). |
| St. James Academy | Lenexa, KS | Coed | 9–12 | ~1,000 | Archdiocese of Kansas City in Kansas; admission includes entrance/placement testing — confirm the current policy and dates (sjathunder.org). |
| St. Teresa's Academy | Kansas City, MO | All-girls | 9–12 | ~570 | All-girls Catholic college prep; confirm the current entrance-test policy and application dates (stteresasacademy.org). |
| Notre Dame de Sion High School | Kansas City, MO | All-girls | 9–12 | ~600 | All-girls, sponsored by the Sisters of Our Lady of Sion; confirm the current entrance-test policy and dates (ndsion.edu). |
| St. Pius X High School | Kansas City, MO (Northland) | Coed | 9–12 | ~415 | The Catholic college prep on the metro’s North side; confirm the current entrance-test policy and dates (spxkc.org). |
| Cristo Rey Kansas City | Kansas City, MO | Coed | 9–12 | ~250 | Corporate work-study model with need-based tuition; confirm the current placement-test and application requirements (cristoreykc.org). |
| Bishop Carroll Catholic High School | Wichita, KS | Coed | 9–12 | ~1,150 | Largest Catholic high school in Kansas (Diocese of Wichita); confirm the current entrance-test policy and dates (bcchs.org). |
| Kapaun Mt. Carmel Catholic High School | Wichita, KS | Coed | 9–12 | ~875 | Reported to use the HSPT; the record we have is unverified, so confirm the current test and date with the school (kapaun.org). |
| Hayden Catholic High School | Topeka, KS | Coed | 9–12 | ~320 | Archdiocese of Kansas City in Kansas; confirm the current entrance-test policy and dates (haydencatholic.org). |
| Maur Hill – Mount Academy | Atchison, KS | Coed (boarding & day) | 9–12 | ~150 | Benedictine coed school with boarding and day options; confirm the current entrance-test policy and dates (mh-ma.com). |
Enrollment figures are NCES Private School Locator 2023–24 counts (rounded), except St. James Academy (~1,000, per the school and Niche 2026 — it is not in the NCES directory feed). Everything else in this table should be re-confirmed with each school before you act on it; admission policies change year to year.
How to choose a Catholic high school in Kansas City
Once the shortlist exists, the decision comes down to five questions — none of which a review score can answer for you:
- Commute: the KC metro spans two states and several highway corridors. A school on the wrong side of the river can add 40 minutes each way — a four-year cost, not a brochure line.
- Single-gender or coed: Rockhurst (all-boys), St. Teresa’s and Notre Dame de Sion (all-girls), and the coed schools (Bishop Miege, St. Thomas Aquinas, St. James, St. Pius X, Cristo Rey, Bishop Carroll, Kapaun, Hayden, Maur Hill–Mount) are genuinely different experiences.
- Size: from Cristo Rey’s ~250 students to Bishop Carroll’s ~1,150 — bigger schools mean more AP sections, sports, and electives; smaller schools mean more individual attention.
- Academics and outcomes: ask each school for recent college matriculation lists and AP offerings, not marketing slogans.
- Cost and aid: every school on this list offers some form of financial aid or scholarships, and HSPT scores often drive merit offers — see our scores & scholarships guide.
For the full framework, read the national best Catholic schools guide, then use the directory pages — Catholic high schools in Kansas and Catholic high schools in Kansas City (MO) — to see the complete local lists.
HSPT & entrance testing for Kansas Catholic high schools
The entrance test is the piece of this comparison every review site misses, and it is the piece that most affects your timeline. The HSPT (High School Placement Test) is the exam most Catholic high schools use for admission, placement, and merit scholarships; a few schools in the region have used the COOP instead — see how the tests differ. Here is what we can verify today:
- Bishop Miege (verified): the HSPT is offered in December, with a priority application deadline in November (source: bishopmiege.com/admissions, checked July 2026). If Bishop Miege is on your list, December is your planning anchor.
- Everyone else (confirm): most KC-metro Catholic high schools require the HSPT or COOP, but each school sets its own exam, date, and retake policy. Confirm with each admissions office before registering — never assume the dates line up across schools.
- Timing: applications for 8th graders open in the fall; HSPT sittings run late fall through winter, with priority deadlines around November–December and regular deadlines into early spring.
Deadlines and test dates are planning inputs, not reasons to pick a school — choose on fit, then build prep around the earliest HSPT date on your list. Our HSPT explainer covers what the test contains, and the HSPT test dates page tracks verified sittings.
FAQs: best Catholic high schools in Kansas
Which Catholic high school is the best?
There is no single “best” Catholic high school — there is a best school for your child. In the Kansas City metro the strongest shortlist usually includes Bishop Miege and St. Thomas Aquinas on the Kansas side, Rockhurst (all-boys), St. Teresa’s Academy and Notre Dame de Sion (all-girls), St. James Academy, St. Pius X, and Cristo Rey Kansas City on the Missouri side. Compare them on commute, single-gender vs. coed, size, academics, and fit — not on one review site’s score.
What is the #1 high school in Kansas City?
Every list answers differently because they measure different things. Niche, Private School Review, and the schools themselves each publish their own #1 — Bishop Miege, St. Thomas Aquinas, Rockhurst, and St. Teresa’s all appear at the top of various lists. A review-score #1 is a starting point, not a verdict: the school that fits your child’s commute, size, and community is the one that matters.
What is the best Catholic high school in Kansas?
For Kansas-side families the field is led by Bishop Miege and St. Thomas Aquinas in the Kansas City metro, St. James Academy in Lenexa, Bishop Carroll and Kapaun Mt. Carmel in Wichita, and Hayden in Topeka. Wichita’s Bishop Carroll is the largest Catholic high school in the state at more than 1,100 students. All are strong schools — the right one is the best fit for your family.
What is the most Catholic town in Kansas?
The town most often cited is St. Marys (Pottawatomie County, about 20 miles west of Topeka) — a small community of roughly 2,800 with a deep Catholic heritage. It is a fun trivia answer, but it shouldn’t drive a school search: what matters is which Catholic high school fits your commute and your child.
Are Catholic high schools better academically?
Catholic high schools on average post strong outcomes — high college-going rates, AP offerings, and small classes — but averages don’t decide your child’s experience. The better comparison is between the specific schools on your shortlist: curriculum, class size, college matriculation, and how your child responds to the environment. Visit campuses and ask about recent graduating classes.
Do Kansas City Catholic high schools require the HSPT?
Most KC-metro Catholic high schools use the HSPT (High School Placement Test) or the COOP for admission, placement, and merit scholarships, but policies differ school by school. The only KC-area HSPT date we have verified is Bishop Miege’s December test. Before you register for anything, confirm each target school’s current exam, date, and retake policy directly with its admissions office.
What is the hardest school to get into in Kansas?
Kansas Catholic high schools do not publish acceptance-rate rankings, and “hardest to get into” changes every year with applicant pools. Selective schools weigh HSPT scores, grades, and interviews together. Instead of chasing selectivity, build prep around the schools on your shortlist: a strong HSPT score is the single biggest admissions and merit-aid lever you control.
Sources: NCES Private School Locator 2023–24 (enrollment, location, grades); school websites and admissions pages (verified July–August 2026); Niche 2026 (St. James Academy enrollment). School details change — confirm admissions information directly with each school before acting on it.
Find out where your child stands before you compare schools.
A free baseline HSPT test shows current strengths and the score range to target — the first fact in your Kansas City school comparison.
3 days free · cancel anytime